For the best experience use full HD.

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

Banished! Again

I've now played ten hours of banished. I am on year ten for my townsfolk. Many things are as I expected them to be. This isn't my first turn on the merry-go-round. However, there have been a couple of surprises that may lead to the ultimate failure of my first town, Netto. Before I get into that though, I want to talk about starting conditions for the game. There are three modes. Here are the exact descriptions from the game.


  • Easy - Six families. A large amount of clothing, food, firewood, building materials, and tools are provided. Homes and storage areas have already been built. Seeds for fields and orchards are available as well as a herd of livestock.

  • Medium - Five families. Clothing, food, firewood, tools and construction materials are provided. A storage barn has already been built. Some seeds for fields and orchards are available.

  • Hard - Four families. A small amount of clothing, food, firewood and tools are provided. No seeds for farming are available.



The default starting mode is medium. On this mode, I found it somewhat challenging to get enough food and firewood for the winter. Fairly quickly I built a Hunting Cabin, a Gatherers Hut and a Herbalist. I also built a Fishing Dock as well as a Woodcutter. This got me through the first winter - just. I ran short of firewood twice, but no one died. I counted that a success. That was the hardest winter I had.

Over then next seven game years everything went well. I added a Blacksmith, Trading Post, Tailor, School and a Forester Lodge. I also created a farm. My average health and happiness remained at four and a half out of five. It was at the start of my eighth year, when I began converting wooden houses to stone houses, that I noticed my first problem. It was not a disaster or anything like that. My population had grown a little since the settlers founded the town, but that had stopped around year five. Now the children had all become students and there were no more children. Then my first adult died of old age. Soon all but one of my students were adult and there were no more children.

Netto Year 10

It turns out there was a very easy to understand reason for this. My houses were full. I had eight people per house. Guess what? People don't fool around in such crowded environments. No hanky panky, no children. It's as simple as that. So I went on a stone house building spree. I increased my first five houses to twelve. That should fix the problem I thought.

And it has, sort of. The second surprise I got from this game is odd. One year of game time does not equal one year of citizen time. The townsfolk age three ot four times faster than the game progresses. When I started looking at their ages, I realized most of my female population had passed into menopause - yes, I believe that is actually programmed into it. I've not seen any children born to a woman past that age. I have 28 people in the village. Only three adult women are under that age, and they all have a child; one actually has two. I did discover they will have children at the medieval correct age of twelve, so that was good. But I am currently looking at an aging population who will soon die off leaving my town without enough people to do everything.

So I am currently stock piling and hoping I can hang on long enough for the children I do have to become adults and have children themselves. I'll need at least two generations to fix my population problem. I'm not certain they'll make it. While they struggle to procreate, I will not be growing the town, that's for certain. My quick start turns out to be a longer range handicap. The game demands a more nuanced strategy than I initially gave it credit for to be honest. Well played Shining Rock Software, well played.

4 comments:

  1. Children are born only in families and new families are only created when there is an empty house for the adult couple to move in. Even if a house is full with 8 peolpe, that's only a single family with the 2 parents and their children.
    The first time I though, my town might be able to survive indefinitely without expanding was at around the pop of 100 ppl in about 20 houses. But I'm still not convinced it could really happen at any point. When you start to get the felling, everything is on a good track, you realize, a good portion of your population is in their age of "sudden death" anytime soon. And when they start to die of old age in a short timeframe, you realize, there's not enough child/students/labourers to take their place soon enough (or you'll get low on other resources).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I got a nasty surprise the other day when one of my critical people died in child birth within the first couple of years. There is a lot of sneaky stuff in that AI!

    ReplyDelete
  3. […] is just a quick update. As you might remember from my last Banished! post, my little group of exiles had a bit of a problem with procreation. They didn’t – […]

    ReplyDelete
  4. […] I have to thank Mabrick for probably killing the next few weeks of my life.  He ran a few articles about Banished, and […]

    ReplyDelete

Be civil, be responsible and most of all be kind. I will not tolerate poor form. There will be no James Hooks here. We are all better than that.